top of page

When Abraham Lincoln Appointed a 10th Supreme Court Justice

By David J. Kent

Washington D.C.

Tuesday, February 23, 2021



ree

Abraham Lincoln is the only president to appoint a tenth justice to the Supreme Court. He made five appointments, one of the most prolific appointers-in-chief in our history. And it all started because of Dred Scott.


In 1857, Chief Justice Roger Taney wrote the 7-2 majority opinion denying Dred Scott and his family the right to live as a free man, returning him to slavery. Taney further declared that African Americans can never be citizens and had no rights to which white men were bound to respect. One of the two dissenters, Justice Benjamin Curtis, was so disgusted he left the court to return to private practice. The second dissenter, John McLean, died a few weeks after Lincoln’s inauguration in 1861. John Campbell, a pro-slavery firebrand, resigned from the Court to become the Confederate Assistant Secretary of War. Lincoln had several vacancies to fill immediately. He did so by nominating Noah Haynes Swayne, Samuel Freeman Miller, and his old friend David Davis, all of whom the Senate quickly confirmed.


While all of us today have seen nine justices all our lives, the Constitution doesn’t actually specify how many Supreme Court justices will sit. Early on that number varied between five and nine. Congress decided to deal with the complications of the Dred Scott decision (including its rather pro-slavery leanings) by adding a tenth justice to the Court. So in 1863 Lincoln was able to fill the extra seat with Steven Johnson Field. Chief Justice Roger Taney then died in October of 1864. After Lincoln won the election in November, he nominated his former Treasury Secretary Salmon P. Chase as the new Chief Justice, his fifth justice appointed. Interestingly, the Court still ruled against Lincoln posthumously in an 1866 case known as Ex parte Milligan in which they determined the Lincoln administration had exceeded its authority by relying on a military tribunal to convict Lambdin Milligan and three others, stating that Indiana civil court should have been employed for the trial.


After Lincoln’s assassination, Congress decided it needed to limit the ability of his successor, Andrew Johnson, from appointing pro-slavery justices to the Court, so they reduced the number to seven. Immediately after Johnson was out of office, Congress reset the number again to nine, and since 1869 that has been the standard to today.


Which means there is precedent for changing the number of justices on the Supreme Court to thwart racist and anti-American behavior by presidents (and the Court itself). That said, there is a reason that the Court has remained stable at nine justices since the aftermath of the Civil War. Also, ten – or any other even number – sets up the potential for a Court mired in constant ties, for which there is no remedy (unlike the Senate, where a tie is broken by the Vice President’s vote). Which means any change in current circumstances would have to be to add two justices to reach eleven. Can it be done? Yes. Should it? That depends on the honesty and integrity of the Senate and President, something that we’ve seen is not always guaranteed.


9 Comments


ayertimeaj
10 minutes ago

Law assignment help provides students with expert assistance in understanding complex legal concepts and completing assignments on time. It covers various areas of law, including contract law, criminal law, constitutional law, and international law. Through professional guidance, students can improve their knowledge of legal principles, case laws, and statutes, ensuring their assignments are well-researched and structured. Law assignment help also offers support in analyzing legal problems, preparing case studies, and writing legal essays. With personalized solutions and expert insights, students can boost their academic performance, meet deadlines, and gain a deeper understanding of legal topics.

Like

ayertimeaj
11 minutes ago

Struggling with marketing assignments? You’re not alone! Whether it's crafting a detailed SWOT analysis, decoding consumer behavior, or building a strategic marketing plan, we know how complex and time-consuming marketing coursework can get. That’s where our Marketing Assignment Help steps in — your shortcut to academic success.

Like

ayertimeaj
15 minutes ago

A program called "Pay someone to take my online class for me" allows students to pay experts to attend and finish assignments, tests, and quizzes for them. Students who struggle with time management, challenging coursework, or personal concerns frequently choose this choice. Although it could appear to be a way to keep up strong grades without exerting much work, there are drawbacks to academic integrity and ethics. Students who are detected utilizing this service may face severe repercussions, including expulsion, as most educational institutions have strong prohibitions against such behavior. The possible effects on academic and personal integrity should be carefully considered.

Like

ayertimeaj
2 hours ago

Hiring growth strategy consultants helps businesses identify opportunities, streamline operations, and accelerate expansion. These experts bring external perspectives, industry insights, and data-driven approaches to create tailored plans. By aligning resources with market trends and competitive positioning, consultants empower companies to scale efficiently, mitigate risks, and achieve sustainable long-term growth.

Like

maxwellmarco
a day ago

Why stay up all night when you can pay someone to take my online class for you and assure better marks? Online courses have the drawback of being tiring. Spending long hours on schoolwork while your socially and academically lives are put on hold is not simple. Not only do they take your assessment, but they also promise passing marks. They only work with the top teachers who have graduated from renowned American universities. They are fully aware of all the requirements, including reference. They have assisted thousands of young people to completely pass the course throughout the years. You can engage them to take the entire course or certain tasks at anytime of the day and night.

Like
Connect
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Lincoln Group of the District of Columbia, PO Box 5676, Washington D.C. 20016

LincolnianDC@gmail.com   All Rights Reserved 2021

bottom of page